Skip to content

Accommodations vs modifications: what is the difference for a child with dyslexia?

Accommodations change how your child learns and shows what they know. Modifications change what your child is expected to learn. The difference sounds technical, but it decides whether your child keeps working toward grade-level goals, so it is worth understanding before the next school meeting.

Published
  • 10 min read
  • 8 sources

Short answer

What is the difference between accommodations and modifications?

An accommodation changes how a student takes in information or shows what they know, without lowering what they are expected to learn: extra time, questions read aloud, typing instead of handwriting. A modification changes what the student is expected to learn or how their work is judged: fewer or easier questions, a shorter spelling list, a lower-level text, or graded against different standards. Accommodations keep a student on grade-level expectations; modifications lower or reduce them. Most students with dyslexia need accommodations rather than modifications, because their difficulty is with reading and spelling words, not with understanding grade-level ideas.

  • Accommodations change how a student learns or is tested; modifications change what the student is expected to learn.
  • Accommodations are commonly grouped into four types: presentation, response, setting, and timing and scheduling.
  • A US IEP must list the accommodations a student needs to take part in state and district tests.
  • States must allow only test accommodations that do not invalidate the score.
  • State guidance warns that modifications can widen the gap between a student and grade-level expectations.

Parents of a child with dyslexia often hear both words in the same meeting, sometimes as if they meant the same thing. A teacher offers to "shorten the spelling list" and "give extra time on tests" in one breath. Both sound helpful. But one of them leaves your child working on the same goals as the rest of the class, and the other quietly lowers them.

This guide explains the difference between accommodations and modifications, shows concrete examples for reading, writing and tests, and explains when each one fits a child with dyslexia. If you are looking for a full list of supports to request, our page on dyslexia accommodations covers that; here we focus on telling the two apart so you can judge any list you are offered.

Accommodations vs modifications: the short answer

An accommodation changes the route, not the destination. Your child still learns the same science, history and math as classmates and is held to the same standard, but the barrier created by slow or inaccurate reading is removed. Listening to the chapter instead of reading it, typing instead of handwriting, having test questions read aloud: the content and the grading stay the same.

A modification changes the destination. Your child is asked to learn less, or something easier, or is graded against a different standard. Fewer questions, a lower-level book, multiple-choice tests with half the options removed: these change what is being measured. State guidance on accommodations, developed with the national association of state school chiefs, puts it plainly: accommodations do not reduce learning expectations, while modifications change, lower or reduce them.

Accommodations vs modifications side by side
What changesHow the student learns or shows learningWhat the student is expected to learn
Grade-level expectationsStay the sameLowered or reduced
GradingSame standard as classmatesDifferent or reduced standard
Typical exampleTest questions read aloudFewer or easier test questions
On state testsAllowed if it does not invalidate the scoreUsually not allowed on regular state tests
Fits most children with dyslexia?Yes, often several at onceRarely, and only for specific tasks

Accommodations vs modifications examples for reading, writing and tests

The easiest way to tell the two apart is to ask one question about any support: does my child still have to learn and show the same thing? If yes, it is an accommodation. If no, it is a modification. The table below applies that question to the situations parents of children with dyslexia meet most often.

Examples of accommodations and modifications for a child with dyslexia
SituationAccommodation (same goal, different route)Modification (different goal)
Reading a class novelAudiobook or text-to-speech alongside the print copyA shorter or simpler book instead of the class novel
Science or history textbookRecorded chapters, text shared in advance, extra timeOnly the summary boxes, with fewer topics to learn
Reading test questionsQuestions read aloud, or text-to-speechSimplified questions that test less
Weekly spelling testAnswers typed or said aloud letter by letter, extra timeA shorter or easier word list than the class
Written assignmentSpeech-to-text, typing, an outline templateA shorter assignment graded on fewer criteria
Copying from the boardPrinted notes or photos of the boardBeing excused from the notes and the content they cover
Multiple-choice testExtra time in a quiet roomTwo answer choices instead of four
Math word problemsProblems read aloudFewer problems, only the easiest ones
Grading writingContent graded separately from spellingGraded against a lower grade-level standard

Notice that the line runs through the middle of almost every situation. Extra time on a spelling test is an accommodation; a shorter spelling list is a modification. An audiobook of the class novel is an accommodation; a different, easier novel is a modification. The same school subject can be handled either way, which is exactly why the words matter.

The four types of accommodations

Accommodations are commonly grouped into four types. Knowing them helps when you read a plan, because a good set for a child with dyslexia usually draws on more than one.

  • Presentation: how information reaches the student without depending on reading standard print. Audiobooks, text-to-speech, questions read aloud, enlarged or well-spaced handouts.
  • Response: how the student shows what they know. Answering orally, typing, speech-to-text, dictating to a scribe, using a spell-checker or a graphic organizer.
  • Setting: where the work or test happens. A quiet room, small-group testing, a seat near the teacher.
  • Timing and scheduling: how much time and when. Extra time, breaks, spreading a long test over two sessions.

Accommodations are not limited to school. A student who listens to texts at school will usually need the same at home, and as they get older, in college and at work. That is one reason to choose accommodations your child can learn to use and ask for independently.

Modifications vs accommodations: why the difference matters

Modifications are not wrong in themselves. For some tasks and some students they are the right call. But they have consequences that accommodations do not, and parents are rarely told about them in the meeting.

Modifications can widen the gap

If a child is taught less, they learn less. State guidance on accommodations warns that modifications can increase the gap between a student and grade-level expectations, and that students who have not had access to the content that is tested may be at risk of not meeting graduation requirements. A shorter spelling list in second grade is small. Years of reduced reading assignments, fewer topics and easier tests add up.

Modifications do not carry over to state tests

On state and district tests, US rules are strict. Each state must publish guidelines that allow only accommodations that do not invalidate the score, and IEP teams must choose from those. A modification such as fewer or simplified questions changes what the test measures, so a regular state test cannot be modified that way. A child who has relied on modified classroom tests may meet the full test for the first time on the day it counts.

Alternate standards are a separate track

There is one formal track with different standards: alternate assessments based on alternate academic achievement standards, which federal rules reserve for students with the most significant cognitive disabilities. Parents must be told that taking part in them may delay or otherwise affect the student completing the requirements for a regular high school diploma. This track is generally not designed for dyslexia, which is a difficulty with words, not with thinking or understanding.

Accommodations vs modifications in an IEP and a 504 plan

In US public schools, support for a child with dyslexia is usually written into one of two plans. An Individualized Education Program (IEP) comes from the Individuals with Disabilities Education Act, which lists dyslexia among the conditions included in a specific learning disability. A 504 plan comes from Section 504 of the Rehabilitation Act, a civil rights law. Our dyslexia accommodations page explains who qualifies for which.

Both plans can include accommodations, and both can in principle include modifications. Federal rules require an IEP to state any accommodations the child needs to take part in state and district tests. The IEP also lists supplementary aids and services and "program modifications or supports for school personnel"; in that phrase, modifications refers to changes the school makes to its program, such as staff training, and does not by itself mean lowering your child's goals. Under Section 504, an appropriate education means regular or special education and related aids and services that meet the student's needs as adequately as the needs of other students are met.

An IEP is reviewed at least once a year, and you can ask for a meeting sooner. That review is the moment to check whether each support is still an accommodation, whether any modification is still needed, and whether your child's reading has improved enough to drop one.

When accommodations fit a child with dyslexia, and when modifications might

Dyslexia is a difficulty with reading and spelling words accurately and fluently. Most children with dyslexia understand grade-level ideas, stories and arguments when they hear them. That is why accommodations are usually the right tool: they remove the word-reading barrier and leave the thinking at full height.

Accommodations fit when the task measures something other than reading or spelling itself: understanding a science chapter, answering history questions, writing an argued essay, solving a math word problem. Listening, typing and extra time let your child show what they actually know.

A targeted modification may fit when the task measures the very skill your child is still building, and the grade-level version is out of reach for now. A child reading two years behind may practice reading aloud with texts at their instructional level rather than the class novel, while still hearing the class novel as an audiobook. That combination keeps the grade-level content and gives reading practice they can actually do.

Neither accommodations nor modifications teach reading. In a meta-analysis of randomized trials with children and adolescents with reading difficulties, systematic phonics instruction was the approach with a statistically significant effect. A plan that adds accommodations without adding reading instruction leaves the underlying difficulty untouched. Ask what the plan does about both. Our guide on how to help a child with dyslexia explains what effective reading support looks like.

How to ask for accommodations instead of modifications

  1. Write down what is hard: list the specific tasks your child struggles with, such as reading test questions in time or copying homework from the board, rather than a general request for help.

  2. Ask the route-or-goal question: for every support offered, ask whether your child still has to learn and show the same thing. Note which items are modifications.

  3. Propose an accommodation first: for each modification, ask whether an accommodation could reach the same goal. Instead of a shorter text, an audiobook of the full one; instead of fewer questions, extra time.

  4. Ask how it shows up on state tests: check that every testing accommodation in the plan is on your state's allowed list, so your child practices with the same supports they will have on test day.

  5. Get it in writing: make sure each accommodation is written into the IEP or 504 plan, with who provides it and in which classes.

  6. Review it: at each review, ask whether any modification can be removed because your child's reading has improved.

If you are not yet sure whether dyslexia is the reason your child is struggling, a skills profile helps you describe the problem precisely. Our free dyslexia test checks phonological awareness, letter sounds, decoding and three other skills in about 8 minutes. It is a screening, not a diagnosis; only a qualified professional can diagnose dyslexia, and our page on how dyslexia is diagnosed explains the evaluation process schools use.

Daily reading practice in your browser

Games in seven worlds, a daily plan built from the test, spaced review, and a parent area with progress, a daily time limit and up to 4 child profiles on one subscription. Works on a computer, tablet or phone.

  • Games in seven worlds: Sound Island, Letter Forest, Word Workshop, Speed Track, Story Harbour, Eagle Eye and Memory Cave
  • A daily plan that starts from the focus skill and adapts as your child improves
  • Spaced review of the letters and words that are still shaky
  • Up to 4 child profiles on one subscription, with a parent area and daily time limit
See the program

Frequently asked questions

What is the main difference between accommodations and modifications?

Accommodations change how a student learns or shows learning, and keep the same expectations. Modifications change what the student is expected to learn or how their work is judged, and lower or reduce those expectations.

Is extra time an accommodation or a modification?

Extra time is an accommodation. The student answers the same questions and is graded the same way; only the time changes. It is one of the most common accommodations for dyslexia.

Is a shorter spelling list an accommodation or a modification?

A shorter or easier list is a modification, because the student is expected to learn fewer or easier words. Typing the answers or spelling them aloud would be accommodations.

Is reading the test aloud an accommodation or a modification?

Reading questions aloud is an accommodation when the test measures something other than reading, such as math or science. On a test that measures reading itself, states set their own rules about whether it is allowed.

What are the four types of accommodations?

Accommodations are commonly grouped as presentation (how information is given), response (how the student answers), setting (where the work happens) and timing and scheduling (how long and when).

Can a 504 plan include modifications?

A 504 plan usually lists accommodations, but it can include other aids and services the student needs. Whatever the plan, ask whether each item changes the route or the goal.

Do modifications affect a high school diploma?

Modified classwork can leave gaps in tested content. Separately, alternate assessments based on alternate standards, meant for students with the most significant cognitive disabilities, may delay or affect a regular diploma, and parents must be told.

Does a child with dyslexia need modifications?

Usually not. Dyslexia affects reading and spelling words, not understanding ideas, so accommodations normally let a child work at grade level. A targeted modification may help for reading practice itself, alongside accommodations.

Sources

  1. Wyoming Department of Education (2006). Accommodations Manual for Instruction and Assessment, developed with the CCSSO State Collaborative on Assessment and Student Standards (SCASS-ASES). Section 2: accommodation categories; modifications vs accommodations.
  2. 34 CFR § 300.320(a)(4), (a)(6) — IEP content: supplementary aids, program modifications or supports for school personnel; accommodations for State and districtwide assessments.
  3. 34 CFR § 300.160 — Participation in assessments: accommodation guidelines (only accommodations that do not invalidate the score); alternate assessments and notice to parents about effects on a regular high school diploma.
  4. 34 CFR § 104.33 — Section 504: free appropriate public education, regular or special education and related aids and services.
  5. 34 CFR § 300.324 — Development, review and revision of the IEP (reviewed at least annually).
  6. 34 CFR § 300.8(c)(10) — IDEA definition of specific learning disability, which includes dyslexia.
  7. Galuschka K, Ise E, Krick K, Schulte-Körne G (2014). Effectiveness of treatment approaches for children and adolescents with reading disabilities: a meta-analysis of randomized controlled trials. PLoS One, 9(2), e89900.
  8. Snowling MJ, Hulme C, Nation K (2020). Defining and understanding dyslexia: past, present and future. Oxf Rev Educ, 46(4), 501-513.